Two Obituaries

Two Obituaries

Jayant Salgaonkar Narendra Dabholkar

20th August 2013 was a bleak day for Maharashtra. Dr. Narendra Dabholkar, crusader against superstition was assassinated by unknown assailants near the Omkareshwar temple in Pune. And Jyotirbhaskar Jayantrao Salgaonkar breathed his last at the Hinduja Hospital in Mumbai. The quirk of destiny (for loss of a better word) and the irony of the events cannot be lost on anybody.That Dr. Dabholkar and Shri Salgaonkar should die on the same day did not seem an irony enough so fate played a game even with locations of their deaths. Dr. Dabholkar, a man of medicine and an atheist was gunned down, reported the journalists, near the Omkareshwar temple; while Jyotirbhaskar left for heavenly abode in one of the most technologically up to date hospitals of Mumbai. The place of their deaths will forever be noted in history.

For all we know these may be random events and it is our compulsion that we envisage a brain or a doer behind every single event. But dimaagh hai ki maanta nahin! We rationalise every event, every single detail of the event. I say even attributing a series of events to destiny is rationalising.

Of the two people, I was acquainted with Jayantrao. My father and he served as trustees on the Siddhivinayak temple. My father is an eminent tax advocate and that was the reason why he was on board as a trustee. He was and continues to be a sort of an atheist. I met Jayantrao a number of times, mostly at cultural programmes. He was a good orator and well read man, in every way a scholar. I remember that I had invited him for the inaugural concert of Jhenduchi Phule, in which I had set to music Acharya Atre’s parodies and satires.

Jyotirbhaskar Jayantrao Salgaonkar

I, like my father, being sort of an atheist have never indulged in rituals of my own accord. It so happened that the pitru-paksha had just started. Apparently, it is a belief that you ought not to buy new things or start new projects during this fortnight. It is considered to be a fortnight of mourning for ancestors. I was blissfully of unaware of all this and in his speech Jayantrao mentioned that he was surprised that I had inaugurated the programme in the pitru-paksha. He said that normally people don’t embark on new ventures during this time. Then he congratulated me on not being superstitious about it and going ahead with the concert. He dismissed all apprehensions of any ill effects of starting new ventures in the pitru-paksha! And the reason he agreed to come, he said, was to quell this superstition!

 Jayantrao was, more than anything else, a successful Marathi entrepreneur. I don’t really know what to make of him as an astrologer as I never looked at him for any predictions. But Kalnirnay as a calmanac and as a magazine was Jayantrao’s great contribution to the Indian ethos. He also sponsored a number of cultural events and encouraged the arts.

Dr. Narendra Dabholkar

On the other hand I had no personal acquaintance with Dr. Narendra Dabholkar but I was and am in complete sympathy & support of the work he was doing. He was the voice of reason in a society desperate to stay unreasonable. I remember Dr. Dabholkar’s appearance in Khupte Tithe Gupte. He invoked stories of Gadge Maharaj to prove his point. He was an articulate speaker and although passionate about his thought, his voice was never shrill. In fact, when he spoke, he reminded me a lot of Dr. Ashok Ranade. His speech was clear, studious, laced with wit and dipped in wisdom. Even in Khupte Tithe Gupte he expressed his displeasure with the Vilasrao Deshmukh government for stalling the Anti-Superstition & Black Magic Bill. He also expressed surprise that it was the members of the ruling party who actually stalled the bill. But not once did his voice betray a hint of anger or ill temper. After all his voice was the voice of reason in the cacaphony of unreasonable arguments. He told tales of Gadge Maharaj and quoted Tukaram verbatim without as much as a chit of paper in his hand. Dr. Dabholkar, I would say, came across as a very spiritual person. And this is not ironical. Spirituality has little to do with religion and absolutely nothing to do with superstition.

What disturbs me however was that Dr. Narendra Dabholkar’s death was not meant to be. His life was interrupted in the most gruesome and inhuman manner. As Hercule Poirot says in almost all his novels – “I don’t approve of murder.” And Dr. Dabholkar’s murder was not just deeply disturbing, it was alarming.

George Bernard Shaw said, “Assassination is an extreme form of censorship.” I have a gnawing feeling that his murder was not the result of fanaticism; it was the result of a corrupt economic and political order. After all superstition, in any faith, is lucrative business. From the people who travel with naked feet to the Siddhivinayak temple to the Novena at the Mahim church to the public display of spiritual healing there is more money involved than spirituality or even religion.

 Aristotle said that democracy is the corrupt form of polity. The degeneration of a democracy is in a public dictatorship – dictatorship of the people, by the people, against the people. Dr. Dabholkar’s assassination proves that. We live in times that has an excess of faith and a shortage of belief – not to mention an absolute dearth of tolerance. There is nobody more relevant than Voltaire today, who said – “I don’t agree with what you say but I shall defend to death, your right of saying so.”

And so while I feel saddened by Jayantrao Salgaonkar’s death as I knew him as an acquaintance, it is Dr. Dabholkar’s death that has moved me and changed something within me. It has been sort of a spiritual awakening. That their deaths came together reminded me that in their lifetimes they existed together and could grow together in opposite directions. Both, in their own ways, contributed to the society. Even today the Dabholkars and the Salgaonkars of our society continue to coexist. And a sane, tolerant society is one where they shall continue to coexist.

© Kaushal S. Inamdar, 2013

Note: The photos have been sourced from the internet. There is no intention to infringe the copyright of the copyright holders. Jayant Salgaonkar’s photo has been sourced from wikipedia. Dr. Dabholkar’s photo has been sourced from


  1. vidya says:

    Truly a moving obituary you have written Kushal…very have penned their qualities so beautifully, that it has provided an insight to your personality.

    May the souls of Dr. Dabholkar and Shri Salgaonkar rest in peace.

  2. sumeet says:

    That's a very poignant article. I completely agree with your views kaushal..It's time for some serious introspection.Democracy is dying,humanity is a word now often seen in books,slowly and gradually,will be seen only in the dictionary.I dont want to sound pessimistic but fanaticism has to end.Healthy debates and not brutal assasinations,are the hallmark of a progressive state.

  3. Kaushal >> Very well written obituary to the two stalwarts. It is indeed very sad and extremely frustrating the way things are going (wrong) with India. Murders, rapes, frauds, scandals seem order of the day. Sadly enough we as a people are no Egyptians or Syrians. Revolt is not in our DNA. Also our enemy is not one dictator but millions of large and small dictators well embedded within us. Not sure which way to look.
    BTW your prose is as elegant and flowing as your music.

  4. You put your heart out while u write..So it's always touching… What I feel is Salgaonkars & Dabholkars will coexist till sane people like you exit in society……

  5. Anonymous says:

    Hi Kaushal .. Ur Article is Deeply Moving .. more so .. bcoz you have so beautifully penned your Thoughts not only about both of them … but also about Democracy thats fading …. May the Souls of Dr.Dabholkar & Shri.Salgaonkar Rest in Peace …

  6. Neha Chinmay says:

    thank u .. U made me look at these two events, in such a different perspective.. i havent read something this clear in ages now..

  7. Aprup says:

    Really very touching & beautifully penned about the two stalwarts in their respective fields.Thank you for this.

  8. Anonymous says:

    Dear Kaushal,
    Your writing is indeed very insightful. Beautiful the way you have given your tribute to the departed souls. As Sumeet says above, the article is indeed very poignant. Bless you.

  9. Living in the US, I read about Dr. Dabholkar's assassination. I had not even heard of Jayantrao's demise, that too, ironically, on the same day. Your obituary is thought-provoking and your pedantic approach is refreshing. May both the departed souls find peace.

What do you think?